PASS 1: Contextual Framework
Case 16: Impaired Engineering
Roles
2
Classes
5
Individuals
States
0
Classes
0
Individuals
Resources
0
Classes
0
Individuals
Extracted Ontology Entities
7 RDF entities extracted organized by concept type
Roles Extraction
New Roles Classes
Classes to Add to proethica-intermediate
These are new roles types not currently in the ontology| Class Label | Definition | Properties & Relations | Source | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Engineer Intern
rdfs:subClassOf Roles |
Graduate engineer working under supervision toward professional licensure, performing engineering work but not yet authorized to take independent responsibility |
Definition:
Graduate engineer working under supervision toward professional licensure, performing engineering work but not yet authorized to take independent responsibility
Professional Scope:
Performing engineering calculations and design work under supervision, developing construction drawings, assisting licensed engineers
Distinguishing Feature:
Typical Qualification:
Generates Obligation:
Associated Virtue:
Relationship Type:
Professional Peer
Domain Context:
Engineering
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Case Example:
|
C16 | |
|
Engineering Firm Owner
rdfs:subClassOf Roles |
Professional engineer who owns and operates an engineering consulting firm, combining technical practice with business management responsibilities |
Definition:
Professional engineer who owns and operates an engineering consulting firm, combining technical practice with business management responsibilities
Professional Scope:
Technical service delivery, business operations management, staff supervision, client relationship management, strategic business planning
Distinguishing Feature:
Typical Qualification:
Generates Obligation:
Associated Virtue:
Relationship Type:
Employer
Domain Context:
Engineering
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Case Example:
|
C16 |
Roles Individuals
Individuals to Add to proethica-case-16
These are specific people, organizations, and entities in this case| Individual | rdf:type | Properties & Relations | Source | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Engineer R
Individual Instance |
EngineerRole |
Title:
structural engineer
Reputation:
well-respected
Specialization:
structural engineering
Case Involvement:
Performed independent review revealing design errors, retained to completely redesign the structure
Active Obligation:
Ethical Tension:
None idtfcas
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Retained_By:
Engineer A
|
C16 | |
|
Engineer A
Individual Instance |
EngineeringFirmOwner |
Title:
Engineer
License:
implied professional engineering license
Specialization:
civil engineering and surveying services
Business Role:
consulting engineering firm owner
Case Involvement:
Building owner whose basement structure failed due to faulty design, chose not to report Engineer B's misconduct
Active Obligation:
Ethical Tension:
Conflict bewrdshpEgBamuS
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Retained:
Engineer B
Retained:
Engineer R
Friend_Of:
Engineer B
|
C16 | |
|
Engineer B's wife
Individual Instance |
ParticipantRole |
Business Role:
took over management of the business
Case Involvement:
Took over management of Engineer B's firm after his stroke
Active Obligation:
Manage business operations
Ethical Tension:
Mangi erbuswthoqlfc
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Married_To:
Engineer B
|
C16 | |
|
Engineer Intern C
Individual Instance |
EngineerIntern |
Title:
graduate engineer employee
Experience:
about two years' experience
License Status:
not licensed
Case Involvement:
Performed structural design and developed construction drawings without proper supervision
Active Obligation:
Ethical Tension:
Aware ofEngiB'smpdctbuky
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Employed_By:
Engineer B
|
C16 | |
|
Engineer B
Individual Instance |
EngineerRole |
Title:
structural engineer consultant
License:
licensed professional engineer
Medical Condition:
suffered a stroke
Business Role:
only licensed professional engineer in his firm
Case Involvement:
Performed faulty structural design while impaired, improperly delegated work to junior engineer
Active Obligation:
Ethical Tension:
Conflict bewads/uygprhm
Generated At Time:
2025-09-25T23:27:50.772845
Friend_Of:
Engineer A
Retained_By:
Engineer A
Employs:
Engineer Intern C
Married_To:
Engineer B's wife
|
C16 |