Edit Step4_provision_validate Template

Step4_provision_validate v2

Viewer

Test Case:

Template

Preview

History

System prompt (optional) User prompt (template)

You are validating that case text excerpts discuss a specific NSPE Code of Ethics provision.

**CODE PROVISION**: {{ provision_code }}
**PROVISION TEXT**: "{{ provision_text }}"

**TASK**: The excerpts below all explicitly mention provision {{ provision_code }}. For each excerpt, determine:

1. **Is it RELEVANT?** Does the excerpt discuss THIS provision's content/requirements?
   - Yes: If it discusses compliance, violation, interpretation, or application of {{ provision_code }}
   - No: If it only cites the number without discussing the content

2. **What is discussed?** (compliance, violation, interpretation, Board reasoning, etc.)

3. **Confidence**: How confident are you? (0.0-1.0)

**EXCERPTS TO VALIDATE**:
{{ mentions_text }}

**OUTPUT FORMAT** (JSON array):
```json
[
  {
    "mention_number": 1,
    "is_relevant": true,
    "confidence": 0.95,
    "content_type": "violation",
    "reasoning": "This excerpt discusses Engineer A's violation of {{ provision_code }} by accepting a contract while serving on the governmental body."
  },
  {
    "mention_number": 2,
    "is_relevant": false,
    "confidence": 0.85,
    "content_type": "citation_only",
    "reasoning": "This excerpt merely cites {{ provision_code }} without discussing what the provision requires or how it applies."
  }
]
```

**IMPORTANT**:
- "is_relevant": true only if the excerpt discusses the provision's CONTENT
- "content_type" options: compliance, violation, interpretation, Board_reasoning, citation_only, background
- Be specific in reasoning - explain what content is being discussed

Loading preview...

Version History

No version history yet. Save changes to create versions.

Saved

1582 chars

Reference

Template Variables

Full text of the provision

NSPE Code provision identifier, e.g. II.4.e

Preformatted MENTION blocks (section, citation, excerpt) for the batch

Output Schema

type array

items

JSON Wrapper

Appended to the prompt by the extractor:

IMPORTANT: Wrap your response as a JSON object with exactly two keys:
{"new_step4_provision_validate_classes": [...], "step4_provision_validate_individuals": [...]}
If there are no individuals to report, use an empty array for "step4_provision_validate_individuals".