Edit Step4_q_analytical Template

Step4_q_analytical v3

Viewer

Test Case:

Template

Preview

History

System prompt (optional) User prompt (template)

You are an ethics analyst examining an NSPE Board of Ethical Review case.

**BOARD'S EXPLICIT QUESTIONS:**
{{ board_q_text }}

**CASE FACTS:**
{{ case_facts if case_facts else "(not provided)" }}

**BOARD'S CONCLUSION:**
{{ case_conclusion if case_conclusion else "(not provided)" }}

**ALL EXTRACTED ENTITIES:**
{{ entities_text }}

{{ provisions_text }}

**TASK:**
Generate analytical questions that deepen understanding beyond the Board's explicit questions.

{% for cat in categories %}{{ loop.index }}. {{ cat.block }}{% if not loop.last %}

{% endif %}{% endfor %}

**FORMATTING RULES:**
- Write questions in plain English. Do NOT embed URIs in question_text.
- Reference entities by their exact label in the mentioned_entities field.
- Generate UP TO 4 questions per category; fewer or zero is acceptable. Emit only
  questions that meet the category's criteria -- do not pad a category to reach a count.
- Link to source Board questions when applicable (source_question field).
- CONTINGENCY ANCHORING (applies to EVERY category): a question whose premise is a
  contingency -- a party's future or hypothetical refusal, rejection, non-compliance,
  or any other event the case does not narrate -- is permitted ONLY when the case text
  itself raises that contingency (in the facts, discussion, or conclusion). If the text
  never discusses the condition, do not ask what should happen under it. (Counterfactual
  questions that NEGATE a stated fact per the counterfactual criteria remain permitted;
  the forbidden form is the un-discussed FORWARD contingency, e.g. "if the client then
  refuses to act, must the engineer escalate?" in a case that never reaches that point.)

**OUTPUT FORMAT (JSON):**
```json
{{ '{{' }}
{% for cat in categories %}{{ cat.example }}{% if not loop.last %},
{% endif %}{% endfor %}
}}
```

Loading preview...

Version History

No version history yet. Save changes to create versions.

Saved

1829 chars

Reference

Template Variables

Numbered board questions, or the no-questions placeholder line

All nine entity types formatted as label plus short definition

CODE PROVISIONS EXTRACTED block (up to 10 provisions, 100-char text cap); empty string when none

Output Schema

keys one array per requested category (implicit, principle_tension, theoretical, counterfactual); the example block in the prompt mirrors the requested subset

format json_object

item_fields

JSON Wrapper

Appended to the prompt by the extractor:

IMPORTANT: Wrap your response as a JSON object with exactly two keys:
{"new_step4_q_analytical_classes": [...], "step4_q_analytical_individuals": [...]}
If there are no individuals to report, use an empty array for "step4_q_analytical_individuals".