Step 3: Temporal Dynamics Pass (Facts)
Extract actions and events from the facts section with Allen's Interval Algebra and causal relationships
Pipeline Steps
Overview Step 1: Contextual Framework Step 2: Normative Requirements Step 3: Temporal Dynamics
Generate Scenario (Coming Soon)
Balancing Client Directives and Public Welfare: Stormwater Management Dilemma
Step 3 of 3
Facts Section
Section Content:
Facts: Engineer L, a licensed professional engineer, has many years of experience in stormwater control design. Engineer L is contracted by Client X, a private development entity, to design a stormwater management system for a large residential and commercial development near a small community. This community relies on a nearby surface water watershed as a primary drinking water source. Part of Engineer L’s scope of work for Client X includes ensuring that stormwater from the new development will not impact this primary drinking water source for the community. During the preliminary design phase, Engineer L becomes concerned that the risk of impact to the community drinking water source will potentially increase, as the likelihood of heavy stormwater flows will increase over time. But before Engineer L can quantify the increased risk, Client X encounters unexpected financial setbacks and requests that Engineer L suspend work identified in the original contract. In their communications about the suspension, Engineer L does not mention to Client X the potential increased risk of impact to the community drinking water source. Several months later, Client X’s financial situation improves and Engineer L is asked to resume work on the stormwater management system. About this same time, an historic heavy rainfall in the region leads to increased stormwater accumulation on-site, raising the risk of runoff into the watershed. Engineer L conducts additional studies and qualitatively estimates the risk that heavy rainfall could lead to stormwater runoff from the development reaching the nearby watershed and community drinking water source. Engineer L notifies Client X of this risk, advising that additional protective measures should be considered, especially as local environmental standards require steps to safeguard public water sources. However, Client X is hesitant to invest in additional protective measures, citing continuing budget limitations. Despite Engineer L’s concerns, Client X insists on proceeding without added safeguards, stating that Client X will address any compliance issues later, if needed.
Actions & Events Dual Extraction
LLM Prompt (Will be displayed after generation)
Click "Extract Actions & Events" to generate and view the prompt...
Allen's Interval Algebra Reference
Temporal Relations Used in Extraction:
- before: A finishes before B starts
- after: A starts after B finishes
- meets: A finishes exactly when B starts
- overlaps: A and B partially overlap
- during: A occurs completely within B
- starts: A and B start together, A finishes first
- finishes: A and B finish together, A starts later
- equals: A and B have same start and end times
- contains: A contains B completely
- started-by: B starts with A, B finishes after A
- finished-by: B finishes with A, B starts before A
- met-by: B finishes exactly when A starts
- overlapped-by: B and A partially overlap (B first)